well-validated antibody, the workhorse of immunofluorescence. If you are a seasoned pro at IF experiments, you are probably used to checking the antibody datasheet (or web page) for the recommended dilution. But have you ever wondered where those recommendations come from?
Primary Antibody Titration
CST scientists routinely perform titrations using positive and negative cell lines to provide you with the recommended dilution that gives optimal signal with minimal background staining. By comparing the "signal" of fluorescence intensities in cells that express the target of interest (positive mean fluorescence intensity, MFI(+)) to the "background noise" of cells that lack expression (negative mean fluorescence intensity, MFI(-)), the signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) can be calculated.
An example of an antibody titration is shown below using an antibody to Mucin-1 (MUC-1), with the optimal concentration/recommended dilution outlined in red. ZR-75-1 cells that express Mucin-1 are shown in the top row, and HCT 116 cells that do not express Mucin-1 are in the lower row. The optimal antibody dilution (outlined in red) has reasonably high signal in the ZR-75-1 cells, and does not exhibit much background (in other words, noise) in the HCT 116 cells, as shown in the IF analysis and in the quantification below.
Optimization of MUC1 (D9O8K) XP® Rabbit mAb #14161 dilution for IF analysis: IF analysis of ZR-75-1 cells (MUC1-positive, upper) and HCT 116 cells (MUC-1-negative, lower) using #14161 (green) at the indicated dilutions. Red = Propidium Iodide (PI)/RNase Staining Solution #4087.
The MFI(+) from ZR-75-1 cells, MFI(-) from HCT 116 cells, and the S/N calculated by dividing MFI(+) by MFI(-) are plotted in the graph below:
Analyis of S/N for MUC1 (D9O8K) XP® Rabbit mAb #14161 dilution. Quantitation of Mean Fluorescence Intensity in expressing (MFI(+), orange) ZR-75-1 cells and non-expressing (MFI(-), blue) HCT 116 cells, and calculated S/N (green).
If the antibody is applied at too low of a concentration, the fluorescence signal will be too dim to distinguish from background noise. On the other hand, an excessively high concentration will contribute to background staining, decreasing S/N. Always check the product datasheet for the recommended dilution.
Primary Antibody Incubation Conditions
All of our recommended primary antibody dilutions are based upon overnight incubation at 4°C. This does not necessarily mean that CST antibodies won't work with a shorter incubation period, which is often used for automated platforms. The concentration of primary antibody may be increased to compensate for shorter incubation times; however, this will increase costs. Temperature is another variable to consider. The following experiment illustrates the dependence of signal intensity on both incubation time and temperature.
Mesenchymal SNB19 cells express the intermediate filament protein vimentin but not the adhesion protein E-cadherin, while epithelial HT-29 cells express E-Cadherin but not vimentin. Analysis of both cell lines was carried out using Vimentin (D21H3) XP® Rabbit mAb #5741 or E-Cadherin (24E10) Rabbit mAb #3195, using each antibody at its recommended dilution and varying temperature and duration of primary antibody incubation.
Examination of signal intensity of #5741 in vimentin-positive SNB-19 cells shows optimal signal levels at the recommended incubation conditions of 4°C/overnight (O/N), while shorter incubation times at higher temperatures yield signal that is significantly lower. Vimentin-negative HT-29 cells incubated with the same antibody O/N are shown for comparison.
Confocal IF analysis of vimentin-positive SNB-19 cells and vimentin-negative HT-29 cells using Vimentin (D21H3) XP® Rabbit mAb #5741 (white). Incubation of primary antibody at its recommended dilution was performed at 4°C, 21°C, or 37°C for 1 hr, 2hr, or overnight (O/N). Conditions recommended by CST for primary incubation (4°C O/N) yield maximum signal with little background (outlined in red). Blue = Hoechst 33342 #4082 (fluorescent DNA dye).
Quantification of Vimentin (D21H3) XP® Rabbit mAb #5741 signal levels in Vimentin-positive cells using a high-throughput laser scanning imaging cytometer shows that the MFI(+) increases with O/N incubation (below, left panel). For 1hr or 2hr incubations, increasing temperature correlates with increasing MFI(+) and S/N , but not enough to match the O/N incubation.
For E-cadherin (24E10) Rabbit mAb #3195, MFI(+) and S/N increase in O/N incubations at either 4ºC or 21ºC (below, right), although not as pronounced as for #5741. Interestingly, in O/N incubations, elevated temperature (37ºC) actually results in lowered MFI(+) and S/N, potentially due to loss of epitope and/or antibody binding. This phenomenon is not observed for the vimentin antibody, likely due to the higher stability of vimentin intermediate filaments. Although the highest S/N for #3195 is observed at higher temperatures, the MFI(+) at 4ºC O/N is close to optimal, and S/N is reasonable.
Not every antibody will have the same response to varying temperature and incubation length. For scientists who are interested in shorter incubations (for example, someone who will be running high-throughput analysis of many samples), performing this type of optimization can be informative. Careful consideration should be given to target abundance and antibody stability when abbreviating the incubation time or modifying the temperature.
Thanks for checking out the Successful Immunofluorescence posts. For more, follow the link below to download the Guide to Successful Immunofluorescence, a handy resource packed with tips and the 9-step Protocol for a Successful Immunofluorescence Experiment.
Already have a copy of the guide? Check out these other IF posts:
XP is a trademark of Cell Signaling Technology.